Annotation:Comely Girl Both Tall and Straight

Find traditional instrumental music

X:1 T:Comely Girl, both Tall and Straight M:4/4 L:1/8 R:Air B:P.W. Joyce - Old Irish Folk Music and Songs, No. 606 (1909) Z:AK/Fiddler's Companion K:G (3DEF|G2 FG E2D2|d3e edBA|G3A BABG|E6 DE| G2 AG E2D2|d2d2 Bdef|g2 fg e2e2|e6 GA| Bdef gfed|B2g2B2A2|G3c BABG|E6 Bd| e3f gfed|B2g2B2A2|GEDE G2G2|G6||

COMELY GIRL, BOTH TALL AND STRAIGHT. Irish, Air (4/4 time). G Major. Standard tuning (fiddle). One part. Joyce obtained the melody from the Forde Collection.

Additional notes
Source for notated version : - Hugh O'Beirne, professional piper[1] Ballinamore, south County Leitrim, 1846, via County Cork collector William Forde (1795-1850) [Joyce].

Printed sources : - Joyce (Old Irish Folk Music and Songs), 1909; No. 606, p. 313.

Back to Comely Girl Both Tall and Straight

(0 votes)

  1. P.W. Joyce concluded that O'Beirne had been a fiddler in his Old Irish Folk Music and Songs (1909, p. 296). However, William Forde, the only collector who had direct contact with O'Beirne, wrote in a letter to John Windele of Cork, dated Sept. 21, 1846, that he had obtained over 150 airs from a piper, Huge Beirne. Forde was seeking to supplement his collection with music from Connaught and the north, and was glad to make the musician's acquaintance, staying on in Ballinamore longer than he originally planned. He also found O'Beirne in poor health in the time of Great Famine, writing "Stirabout and bad potatoes were working fatally on a sinking frame," and aided the piper by improving his diet ("but a mutton chop twice a day has changed Hugh's face wonderfully").